Today's question comes from a real headline: Alpha Schools is opening a campus in Chicago this fall where AI handles all academic instruction and there are no classroom teachers — just adult "guides."

The school charges $55,000 per year and claims their students rank in the top 1% nationally.

Here's my honest take: AI tutoring works — the research confirms it. But there's a massive difference between AI as a supplement to great teaching and AI as a replacement for it. The most effective models pair AI tools WITH trained educators, not instead of them.

What's your gut reaction? Could you see a school like this working for certain students? Or does removing teachers from the equation fundamentally change what "education" means?

Drop your honest take below — I'm especially curious what educators in the community think about the "guide" model.